Whether you’re a novice cook or veteran baker, it’s safe to say that you need a high-quality pie dish. If you’re starting with a well-designed pie plate, you can obtain excellent baking results regardless of your skill level. Choosing the best pie dish isn’t very simple when you check out the overwhelming market featuring countless options. There are different materials and styles to select so the whole process can become very confusing.
If you’re interested in superior value for the money, this article provides a curated selection of the best pie dishes available right now. We’ve taken care of the research process to ensure that you’re getting a reliable accessory for making your favorite pies. When it comes to pie pans, three material options stand out. Glass models are very popular due to being affordable and practical in terms of heat distribution. The transparent design makes it easier to check the texture of the crust. Ceramic pie dishes are more aesthetically pleasing and yield gradual and even heat buildup. Another solid construction option is metal such as aluminum. It’s recommended for efficient heat conductivity and durability but can suffer from over-browning issues.
Best Ceramic Pie Dish
1. Emile Henry Modern Classics Pie Dish
The Emile Henry Modern Classics series of pie dishes is worth exploring if you want to bake like a pro. As opposed to cheap options out there, this is a premium pie plate made in France using top-quality natural ceramic. It boasts amazing heat-retention performance that results in consistently great pies. At the same time, the pie dish promises great resistance to scratches and cracking.
The glaze finish has been reinforced for busy kitchens where tasty desserts are prepared frequently. In terms of cleaning, the pie dish is dishwasher-friendly. It can withstand up to 520 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven while providing good compatibility with a freezer. When it comes to aesthetics, this is an elegant pie dish featuring different color finishes for a personalized look. If you’re looking for a deep pie dish, the 2.6” depth can easily match your needs.
2. Farberware Baker’s Advantage Pie Dish
With a fun teal color and sturdy ceramic construction, the Farberware Baker’s Advantage pie dish can be considered a valuable choice for the money. This is an excellent piece of stoneware that doesn’t absorb odors and guarantees consistent baking results. The glazed finish gives the pie plate a more distinctive appearance suitable for any kitchen. It’s recommended to wash it by hand to maintain it in top shape.
Whether you want to make savory blueberry pies or tasty meat pies, this is the right tool for the job. Thanks to the solid ceramic material used, the pie dish heats up more uniformly and cooks better compared to other options. This piece of bakeware can be safely used in the oven or microwave. Although the long-term durability might not be as great as more expensive options, this is a solid pie dish available at a reasonable cost.
3. Le Creuset Stoneware Pie Dish
An outstanding choice if you value durability above all else, the Le Creuset enameled pie dish collection shouldn’t be overlooked. The brand has a long history when it comes to artisanal stoneware construction and authentic design focused on premium quality. Regardless of the type of pie you’re making, you can expect consistent results each time. Thanks to an advanced high-temperature treatment process, the pie dish provides unrivaled thermal resistance.
The durable construction is the secret behind its impressive ability to heat up evenly. And that’s also the reason for the higher cost. Whereas cheaper pie plates can start cracking or crazing after some time, this model has extremely low porosity to minimize any risk of moisture infiltration that causes such common problems. The dense qualities of stoneware make this pie dish suitable for the dishwasher and a wide range of appliances such as the freezer or the microwave.
Best Glass Pie Dish
4. Pyrex Easy Grab Pie Dish
If you’re a fan of classic glass pie dishes, it’s safe to say that you’ll be hard-pressed to find a better option than Pyrex. Trusted for more than a hundred years to manufacture premium bakeware in the US, this 9.5-inch glass pie plate won’t disappoint. It comes as a convenient set of two pieces for flexible baking of your favorite pie recipes.
Thanks to the flawless non-porous design of the glass, there’s no risk of flavor mixing when cooking with these pie dishes. You don’t have to worry about stains either considering how easy it is to clean the plate. In terms of looks, the pie dish may not have the kind of rustic appearance of glazed ceramic but the transparent design is arguably more useful. The pie dishes still seem very attractive thanks to the textured rims that help to ensure a more confident grip.
5. Wisenvoy Ceramic Pie Dish
Ceramic pie dishes are often favored by bakers who want an ideal blend of functionality and beautiful aesthetics. This elegant pie plate from Wisenvoy could be a smart investment to consider. It features stylish floral patterns on its colorful glazed finish. The rustic appeal of the dish will surely make it stand out in your kitchen.
Although it has great decorative potential, the pie dish is also a multifunctional bakeware item that you can really depend on. It makes use of a robust porcelain construction, a solid type of ceramic that can withstand use in the oven, microwave, broiler, and freezer. The pie dish appears delicate at a first glance but it’s actually surprisingly durable. It delivers great heat retention and can be cleaned in the dishwasher. A superb mix when taking into account its old-fashioned elegance.
6. KOOV Ceramic Pie Dish
Designed for delicious homemade desserts, this ceramic pie dish made by KOOB represents a reliable solution without breaking the bank. The pie plate is available in a few colors such as pale blue, red, and white. It’s a 9-inch dish suitable for a wide range of savory pies. Each ceramic pie dish has been treated with a special glazed finish to face against scratches while maintaining its colorful look.
When it comes to the baking experience, this pie dish has a lot to offer. It’s a good match for the oven and the microwave as well as the refrigerator. The coating has non-stick properties that help with food release. It’s recommended to wash this pie plate by hand even though it’s dishwasher-friendly. This is a fairly versatile pie dish considering its depth of 2.4 inches that shouldn’t cause overflowing problems.
7. Wireless The Pi Dish Pie Plate
Anyone looking for a pie plate with a humorous design should take a look at The Pi Dish. It’s an ideal gift for those who enjoy good puns. The pie dish doesn’t just feature the “Pi” symbol on the inside but also has the first 100 numerals of Pi on the outer rim. It’s a distinctive design choice that makes it a suitable pie dish for any math enthusiast that also likes pies.
Aside from the unique look, the pie plate also performs great when it comes to baking pies. It’s built using glazed stoneware that makes it safe to use in high-heat environments such as the oven. The thick ceramic guarantees consistent cooking results but the coating can be quite vulnerable in the dishwasher. It’s best to stick to handwashing for this model.